How to choose a marketing agency: A 6-step process from brief to first project
To choose a marketing agency, write down the job before you meet anyone, shortlist 4 to 6 candidates, give each the same brief, score the pitches against weights you set in advance, speak to references, and start with a paid first project rather than a long contract. The whole process fits in about 4 weeks.
You're an operating partner, or the CEO of a company you have just bought, and the value-creation plan has a marketing line that needs delivering. Every agency looks credible in a pitch, so the choice comes down to the process you run.
Key takeaways
- Write a one-page brief that names the job, the buyer, and the deadline before you meet anyone.
- Shortlist 4 to 6 candidates, and give each the same brief and the same 60 minutes.
- Score pitches against weights you set in advance, so the best presenter does not win by default.
- Speak to 3 references per finalist, including one former client.
- Start with a paid first project of 30 to 60 days, then decide on the longer contract.
Define the job, the buyer and the deadline before contacting agencies
Agencies pitch well to a vague brief, so a one-page brief matters, and it should come straight from the marketing line in your value-creation plan, as the marketing workstream inside a value-creation plan sets out. The brief needs 4 things:
- The job. One sentence with a number and a date, for example 20 qualified meetings with larger buyers by the end of next quarter.
- The buyer. Who you want to reach, and who is closing today if that has changed since the deal.
- What already exists. Positioning, a CRM, content, and who inside the company owns each.
- The limits. A budget range, who signs off, and what the one or two marketers will keep doing themselves.
If you cannot write the job in one sentence, the first project is deciding it.
Build a shortlist of 4 to 6 from peers, your portfolio network, and a short search
Start with people who have bought this before: Ask 2 or 3 peers at other portfolio companies who they use and why, then run a short search to fill the gaps. A shortlist of four to six agencies is enough, because fewer gives you little to compare and more costs everyone time.
Before you add a name, decide which kind of provider fits the job. An agency, a part-time leader, and a full-time hire solve different problems, and who actually does marketing for mid-market portfolio companies compares them at this company size.
Then email each candidate 2 screening questions: Whether they have worked with companies of 40 to 200 people, and who would run the account.
Give every agency the same brief and 60 minutes to pitch
A fair comparison needs identical inputs. Send the one-page brief 5 working days ahead, set a 60-minute slot for each candidate, and ask for the same 3 things: How they would learn your buyer, who would do the work each week, and a 90-day outline with dated outputs.
Ask them to leave finished creative out, since spec work rewards whoever has the most free time to give away.
The strongest answers on learning your buyer start with customer conversations and a written positioning answer, and positioning workshop or buyer interviews covers the trade-off between a workshop and a round of 15 to 20 interviews.
Score each pitch against weights you set before the first meeting
Weights agreed in advance stop the most polished presenter from winning by default. This starting set can be adjusted to the job:
| Criterion | Suggested weight | What to look for |
|---|---|---|
| Fit with your buyer | 25 | Experience with companies of your size, and a clear plan to learn your buyer |
| Senior people on the work | 20 | Named people you have met, with their weekly time on your account stated |
| Evidence in similar companies | 20 | Case studies with timeframes and outcomes you can verify |
| Reporting and ownership terms | 15 | Reporting in qualified pipeline, and the company owning every account and login |
| Speed to the first output | 10 | A dated plan for the first 30 days |
| Total cost over 12 months | 10 | Fees, minimum term, and exclusions, compared on one basis |
Each person scores alone, then you compare. Where two scores differ by more than 2 points out of 5, talk through why, since the gap is usually a difference in what each person heard. For the cost line, compare 12-month totals, and what you should budget for marketing after an acquisition shows how to build that number.
Speak to 3 references per finalist, including one who has left
References chosen by the agency will be positive, which is fair, so use them for specifics rather than endorsement. These 4 questions work well:
- What happened in month 3, once the early excitement had settled?
- Who did the day-to-day work, and did that change after the contract was signed?
- Which report did you rely on, and did it match your own sales numbers?
- What would you change about how you started?
Then find 1 former client yourself, through your network or a professional profile. How an agency handles a difficult month tells you more than its pitch, and good agencies welcome the check.
Start with a paid 30-to-60-day project before signing a longer contract
Even a strong process leaves some uncertainty, and a short paid project reduces it cheaply. Pick work with a clear end, such as a written positioning answer or a marketing audit, agree dated outputs and a notice period, and decide on the longer contract once you have seen the team work. Good agencies welcome this, because it lets them prove the fit.
The first project should match where the company is in the months after close, and the 100-day marketing plan for a newly acquired company sets out a realistic order of work.
A 4-week timeline from brief to signed first project
The whole process fits in about 4 weeks:
- Week 1. Write the brief, build the shortlist, and send the screening questions.
- Week 2. Run the 60-minute pitches, with the same 3 requests for each candidate.
- Week 3. Score alone, compare, and take up references for the 2 finalists.
- Week 4. Agree the first project, its dated outputs, and the notice period, then sign.
Put a decision date in the brief at the start, so every candidate works to the same deadline.
Why a 60-person Nordic software company chose a partner that started with buyer interviews
Take a newly acquired Nordic software company we work with: Around 60 people, 600+ customers, two marketers, no CMO. The product was strong, demand came almost entirely by word of mouth, and the website still described the smaller customer the company was leaving behind.
The company chose a partner on the strength of how it would learn the buyer. The work began with 15 to 20 buyer interviews and a written positioning answer, then moved to content and search, then a systems rebuild, with new markets held for later.
FAQ
How long does it take to choose a marketing agency?
About 4 weeks from brief to signed first project: 1 week for the brief and shortlist, 1 for pitches, 1 for scoring and references, and 1 to agree terms.
How many marketing agencies should you shortlist?
Aim for four to six agencies. Fewer than four gives you little to compare, and more than six takes up time for both your team and the agencies without improving the decision.
What should a marketing agency include in its pitch?
Ask for how it would learn your buyer, the named people who would do the work with their weekly time, a 90-day outline with dated outputs, and how it would report progress in qualified pipeline.
Should a company of 40 to 200 people choose a marketing agency or a full-time marketing leader?
An agency is usually the better choice when the company has clear marketing priorities and needs specialist support to deliver content, campaigns or search. A full-time marketing leader makes more sense when someone needs to set direction, manage the team, own the budget and work closely with sales and product. If the positioning is still unclear, resolve that first before committing to either option. Fractional CMO, agency, or hire compares the three approaches in more detail.
Can you work with a marketing agency while a CMO search is open?
Yes, and many companies do. Choose a first project with a defined end, such as positioning, so the leader you hire arrives to finished work, as the CMO gap explains.
Write the brief, score the pitches, and judge the agency on a paid first project
Name the job on one page, shortlist 4 to 6, give everyone the same brief, score against weights set in advance, speak to references including a former client, and start with a paid first project. Run in 4 weeks, the process leaves you choosing on evidence. No random acts of marketing.
If you would like to see how a small senior team approaches the first 90 days for a company you have just bought, the value-creation programme for portfolio companies sets out how the work runs and where to book a strategy session. You will leave with a bird's-eye plan, whether or not we work together.
Ready to put your content to work?
Book a discovery call